THE PULSE
the business of creativity
Breaking

Meta, TikTok, YouTube and Snap push back on Australia's digital duty of care bill

At a Senate inquiry, the platforms backed the bill's aims but called it vague and rushed. They warned of over-moderation, and YouTube said under-18s could be locked out of Gmail. Independent senator David Pocock confronted TikTok over self-harm content.

By · November 9, 2026
Image © The Collab Report

Updated November 20, 2026: The Senate committee reported on November 20, recommending the bill be passed subject to its recommendations; the Coalition dissented and the Greens set conditions for their support.

Meta, Google, TikTok and Snap told an Australian Senate inquiry on Monday that they back the aims of the government's Digital Duty of Care bill, but argued it is vague, too broad and rushed. The bill has passed the House of Representatives, and the Senate committee examining it reported on November 20, recommending that it pass, subject to its recommendations.

What the bill does

The Online Safety Amendment (Digital Duty of Care) Bill 2026 would put a legal duty on online services, from social platforms to search engines and AI tools, to take reasonable steps against harm to their users. According to the ABC, companies that fail to manage the risks could face fines of up to A$109 million. The bill would also ban "nudify" apps and give users the choice to opt in or out of the algorithm that ranks their feeds.

A legal analysis by Johnson Winter Slattery says platforms would have to write risk assessments at least once a year and before any significant product change, and hand them to the eSafety Commissioner on request. The core duty would start 12 months after the law passes. Reuters reported that Communications Minister Anika Wells wants it through Parliament by the end of the year. "If you build it, you should be responsible for its harms," Wells told the ABC.

What the platforms said

TikTok's Jessika Lofstedt said the bill creates ambiguity and could lead to "overzealous moderation", according to the ABC. Reuters reported that representatives of Meta, TikTok and Snap all warned that the broad definitions of harmful content would give the regulator wide discretion over what they must take down.

Rachel Lord, YouTube's head of policy for Australia and New Zealand, said the age-check rules for services where children could see pornography do not exempt email or messaging. "It could require us to age assure and block access to everyday communication services," she said, as reported by Reuters, raising the prospect of under-18s being blocked from Gmail.

Meta's Mia Garlick said it would be hard to amend the bill in its current form to let individuals sue for damages, which the Greens are pushing for. "Our primary focus is on compliance and avoiding having to discuss penalties," she told the committee, according to AAP.

The sharpest exchange came from independent senator David Pocock. He brought printed examples of self-harm posts to the hearing, including one Mumbrella reported had around 480,000 likes. "How can you seriously try and tell the committee that you don't have that content on your platform when you clearly do?" he asked, according to AAP. Lofstedt said self-harm content breaks TikTok's rules, offered to review any examples, and conceded: "We don't get it right every time."

What the regulator said

On the second day of hearings, on November 10, eSafety Commissioner Julie Inman Grant pushed back on the platforms' warnings about over-moderation. "Companies today are trying to show the maximum amount of material, no matter how harmful or hurtful it is," she told the committee, according to AAP. eSafety's general counsel, Richard Fleming, said: "Over-blocking and over-compliance certainly isn't what we see."

Inman Grant said "a very good job has been done at this first pass", but she raised a concern of her own, AAP reported. The bill would replace the existing online safety codes and standards, which the industry drafted, with guidance that cannot be enforced. She proposed ministerial directions approved by Parliament instead.

AAP also reported that the Coalition will oppose the bill over censorship concerns, while the Greens have flagged Senate amendments for higher fines and a right for citizens to take big tech to court. The government wants the bill passed in the Senate's final sitting week of 2026, which starts on November 23, AAP reported.

The committee's report, released on November 20, recommended that the Senate pass the bill "subject to consideration" of its recommendations, NCA NewsWire reported. Those include carving out low-risk sites, such as small business websites and religious sites aimed at education or doctrinal instruction, and checking how well the scheme deals with online hate and vilification based on race, gender, sexuality and disability, according to AAP. NCA NewsWire said the committee also urged the government to add a civil right of action so individuals can sue. In a dissenting report, Coalition senators called the bill "so deeply flawed and so ill-conceived that it should never have seen the light of day". Greens senator Sarah Hanson-Young said that if the government wants the bill passed this year, "they will need to work with the Greens to give it real teeth". The Greens want a private right of action and fines of 10% of a company's global revenue, NCA NewsWire reported. AAP said the bill is likely to pass with Greens support.

What it means for creators

The bill is aimed at platforms, not the people who post on them. But creators feel any rule that changes how platforms moderate and rank content. If the platforms are right that the definitions are loose, they are likely to remove more borderline material rather than risk a nine-figure fine. Creators who cover mental health, fitness, body image and other sensitive subjects would be hit first. A real choice to switch off algorithmic feeds would also make reach less predictable for creators who depend on For You-style discovery.

The bill excludes professional news content. Johnson Winter Slattery notes that this exclusion depends on editorial independence and standards, so news-style creators, podcasters and newsletter writers should check whether their editorial policies would qualify. The firm also says sponsored or brand-funded content may not be covered by the exclusion.

What it means for brands and agencies

Australia is already enforcing its under-16 social media ban. This bill would add a standing duty on top, so brands should expect platform safety settings to tighten before it starts. Campaigns aimed at younger audiences or in sensitive health categories should plan for stricter moderation.

Why it matters: With the under-16 ban in force and a duty of care on the way, Australia is becoming one of the toughest test markets for platform regulation. What the Senate does with this bill in the coming weeks will shape how Australian creators are moderated and found, and other countries are watching.