THE PULSE
the business of creativity
Opinion

Brussels is right to make brands pay when influencers hide the ad

The Digital Fairness Act would make brands and agencies responsible for their creators' ad labels. The industry wants enforcement of the old rules instead. Europe has tried that, and four in five influencers still didn't disclose consistently.

By Editorial Board · November 12, 2026
Image © The Collab Report

For a decade, the creator has been the one left holding the risk when a paid post goes out unlabelled. Regulators write to the influencer, the press names the influencer, and the brand that paid for the post usually stays in the background.

The European Commission's Digital Fairness Act, unveiled on Wednesday, would change that. Brands and agencies would be responsible for making sure the creators they pay disclose the ad. The advertising industry will spend the next year trying to water that down. It should not succeed. Making the brand pay is the most important idea in the whole package.

What Brussels is proposing

Under Article 11 of the proposal, creators would have to label paid posts clearly with the words "advertisement" or "commercial collaboration". Any company using influencer marketing would have to make sure, "contractually, or in the absence of a contract through other appropriate means", that the creator complies, PPC Land reported from the published text. The recitals name companies selling branded products and advertising agencies, and say they are liable whatever form the payment takes and however much creative freedom the creator has. Gifts and invitations count as payment.

The Commission put it plainly in its Q&A: "Brands and agencies will have to ensure that influencers comply with their obligations."

The current rules have already failed

The industry's main argument is that Europe does not need new rules, only better enforcement of the old ones. In July 2025, a coalition led by IAB Europe wrote to the Commission arguing that existing consumer, digital services and data protection law already covered these concerns, and that enforcement should come first, according to PPC Land.

That argument has been tested. In February 2024, the Commission and consumer authorities from 22 member states, plus Norway and Iceland, checked the posts of 576 influencers. Nearly all of them, 97%, posted commercial content. Only one in five consistently said it was advertising. The sweep led to 358 influencers being flagged for further investigation by national authorities. Sweden's consumer agency found the same problem this year, as we reported, and wrote to about 40 influencers and advertisers after spot checks.

Brands that commission influencer ads can already be liable under the current directive, law firm Osborne Clarke has noted, but enforcement has mostly meant chasing creators one by one, many of whom earn modest sums. There are far fewer brands and agencies, and they have legal teams, compliance budgets and the contract that sets the rules of the job. If you want behaviour to change, you put the duty on the party with the money and the paperwork.

The objections, taken seriously

There are fair worries. Small brands that send out free products will now have to tell creators the rules and check what gets posted. That is extra work. But the alternative is a system where a gift box buys a glowing review and nobody is responsible for telling the audience. If a brand cannot keep track of who it has paid in product, it is not ready to run an influencer programme.

The bigger worry is for creators. Brands that carry the legal risk will want more control: approval rights, script checks, the power to demand edits. Some will use liability as an excuse to micromanage. Creators should push back on that in negotiations. Checking that a label is present is not the same as rewriting the post, and the proposal says liability applies however much creative freedom the creator has. Brands do not need editorial control to meet this duty.

Others say the proposal does too little. Finance Watch said it "does nothing to stop unqualified influencers from pushing risky products", PPC Land reported. That is a fair criticism of the finance rules, and Parliament should take it up. It is not a reason to drop the brand duty.

Illustration: The Collab Report

The public is ahead of the industry

Most people already think this is reasonable. Of the 1,733 consultation responses that were not part of organised campaigns, 68% backed binding EU rules on influencer marketing, according to PPC Land's reading of the Commission's documents. Agustín Reyna, director general of the consumer group BEUC, told EUobserver that "people expect that influencers provide genuine advice or tips". Audiences are not asking creators to stop doing paid work. They are asking to be told when it is paid.

What it means for creators

This is good news, even if it does not feel like it yet. Clear labels protect the trust that creator businesses depend on, and shared liability means you are no longer the only target when a campaign goes wrong. Read your next contract carefully. Accept a disclosure clause, but resist clauses that hand the brand creative control in the name of compliance.

What it means for brands and agencies

Do not wait for the final text. The proposal still needs agreement from the European Parliament and member states, and would apply 12 months after it comes into force. But a brief, a disclosure clause and a simple check of each post cost little. Brands that build those habits now will not be scrambling later. And Britain, which has its own labelling problem, should watch closely.

Why it matters: Europe has tried enforcing disclosure one creator at a time, and four in five still did not label their ads consistently. Making brands and agencies answerable puts the duty where the money and the contracts are, and lobbyists should not be allowed to talk Brussels out of it.

This is the view of The Collab Report's editorial board. Disagree? Tell us, and we may publish the best responses.