Hidden ads are consumer fraud. It's time to fine the influencers who post them.
Britain has spent a decade asking creators nicely to label their ads. It now has the power to fine them. It should use it, and so should Europe.

Every few months the UK's Advertising Standards Authority publishes a ruling against an influencer who forgot, or "forgot", to say a post was an ad. The creator deletes the post, maybe adds "#ad" to the next one, and carries on. The brand that paid for it usually carries on too. This has been going on for more than ten years. It has not worked.
In October the ASA and the Competition and Markets Authority published a new edition of their influencer guide. It is sensible. It says labels like "spon" and "sp" may not be clear enough, that "#ad" should come first, and that creators must not claim to have used products they have not. The most important change is not in the advice, though. It is the legal basis underneath it. The guide now rests on the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, which gives the CMA the power to fine businesses directly for breaking consumer law, without first going to court.
The regulator has the power. It should use it on influencers, not only on the brands behind them.
This is not a paperwork error
The industry likes to frame hidden ads as a labelling problem, as if creators are confused about where to put a hashtag. They are not. A creator who has signed a contract, agreed a brief and invoiced a brand knows the post is an ad. Leaving the label off is a choice, and it is made for one reason: unlabelled posts sell better, because followers trust them more.
That trust is the whole business. A creator's audience gives them attention because they believe the recommendation is honest. Selling that belief to a brand while pretending it is still honest is not a grey area. In any other part of retail, presenting a paid endorsement as an independent review would be called what it is: misleading consumers for money.
"But small creators can't afford fines"
This is the main objection, and it is backwards. Small creators are not the problem. The posts that do the most damage come from large accounts promoting things like crypto schemes, unregulated supplements and high-interest credit to audiences that skew young. Those creators earn real money and use agents, managers and lawyers. They can afford to read a two-page guide.
Fines should scale with reach and income, as they do for businesses. A first-time slip by someone with 3,000 followers deserves a warning. A creator with a million followers who hides a paid crypto promotion deserves a fine that costs more than the fee they were paid. Anything less is a licence fee for deception.
Brands should pay too
Fining creators does not let brands off. The company that wrote the brief and signed the cheque should share liability for every undisclosed post it paid for. If brands knew they would be fined alongside the creator, contracts would require labels on day one and agencies would check them before payment. That would do more than a hundred more guidance documents.
Europe should take note. The European Commission is expected to present its Digital Fairness Act next week, with influencer marketing on the agenda. It should skip the decade of polite reminders Britain went through and start where the UK has finally arrived: with enforcement that hurts.
Honest creators are the ones losing
Here is the part the industry rarely says out loud. Every creator who labels their ads properly is competing against creators who don't, and losing. The honest post gets less engagement. The honest creator looks less authentic in a brand's report. The current system punishes the people following the rules.
Real fines would fix that. They would make honesty the normal cost of doing business rather than a competitive disadvantage. If creators want to be treated as a serious profession, with tax treatment, trade bodies and a seat at the table in Brussels, they have to accept the obvious condition that comes with it: when you are paid to say something, you say so.
This is the view of The Collab Report's editorial board. Disagree? Tell us, and we may publish the best responses.