THE PULSE
the business of creativity
Opinion

British newspapers are losing their stars to the creator economy, and they deserve to

Marina Hyde left the Guardian for her own Goalhanger-backed brand, and Amol Rajan left Today to start his own company. Publishers call it a talent drain. It is a verdict on their deal.

By Editorial Board · November 13, 2026
Image © The Collab Report

When news broke in September that Marina Hyde was leaving the Guardian after more than a quarter of a century, the obvious question in British media was which paper had poached her. None had. Her final column ran on 2 October, and she now writes and presents Always On, her own brand: a newsletter plus a YouTube show covering politics, entertainment, sport and the media, according to ResponseSource. Press Gazette reported that it is backed by Goalhanger, the podcast company behind The Rest Is Entertainment, which she still co-hosts with Richard Osman.

A month earlier, Amol Rajan presented his last Today programme on BBC Radio 4. He gave up one of the most prominent chairs in British broadcasting to set up his own production company, though he still hosts University Challenge for the BBC.

Newspapers and broadcasters tend to describe these exits as a loss, as if the talent had been lured away. We think they should read them as a verdict. Britain's news organisations are losing their best-known names to the creator economy because the creator economy offers something they refuse to: a real share of the audience the talent brings in. Until they change that, they deserve to lose more.

Follow the money

Goalhanger's accounts show why the pull is so strong. The company made a pre-tax profit of £10m in 2025 on turnover of £38m, City AM reported. Paid subscribers more than doubled to 243,000, its shows were played 667m times, and it paid about £5m in dividends. It did that with 54 staff.

The terms are the other half of the story. Press Gazette reported that Goalhanger's revenue share on podcast and video is believed to be 50/50. On Substack, writers keep at least 85% of subscription revenue after the platform's 10% commission and payment fees. Press Gazette editor Dominic Ponsford wrote that Goalhanger and Substack offer "a level of creative freedom" that talent is unlikely to enjoy at legacy publishers.

Compare that with what was happening inside traditional newsrooms in the same weeks. Press Gazette reported that DMGT was proposing about 60 job cuts at Metro, and that Axel Springer was examining proposals for up to 100 newsroom redundancies at the Telegraph. A star columnist on a salary takes home a fixed wage while the brand they help to sell makes those cuts. A star on a creator deal takes half of what they earn.

This is a pattern, not a one-off

Hyde and Rajan are not the first to go. Emily Maitlis, Jon Sopel and Lewis Goodall left the BBC in 2022 to start The News Agents at Global. Piers Morgan took Piers Morgan Uncensored independent on YouTube in 2024. Each move was treated at the time as an unusual career choice. Taken together, they show a clear route out for any journalist with a loyal following.

The wider market is growing too. UK creator revenue is expected to pass £1bn for the first time this year, according to IAB figures cited by Marketing Week. Journalists who can hold an audience on camera are now competing in that market whether their employers like it or not.

Image © The Collab Report

The case for the newsroom, taken seriously

There are strong arguments on the other side, and they deserve a hearing. A newspaper gives a columnist editors, sub-editors, fact-checkers and, crucially, lawyers. A solo creator who gets a story wrong has no institution standing behind them when the legal letter arrives. Big outlets make mistakes too, but they have systems for correcting them.

The star system also concentrates rewards. For every Hyde there are hundreds of reporters doing court reporting, council meetings and investigations that no audience will ever pay a personal subscription for. If the best-known names take their fans and leave, the people left behind are the ones whose work is hardest to fund. And it was often the masthead that made the star famous in the first place.

All true. But none of it explains why publishers should keep the upside for themselves. If the masthead's support is so valuable, publishers can charge for it, as Goalhanger does, rather than insisting on owning everything. The newsroom's real advantages, editing, legal cover and distribution, are exactly what a good label offers its artists. Publishers could offer equity, revenue shares, personal channels inside the brand, and the right to take an audience with you after a fair notice period. Most have chosen not to.

What it means for creators

If you are a journalist with a following, the market now values you as a creator, and you should negotiate like one. Ask who owns your audience data, your video archive and your newsletter list. The best deals on offer split revenue, they do not just pay a wage. Before going solo, though, budget for the things a newsroom gave you for free: an editor, a lawyer and someone to say no.

What it means for brands and agencies

Trusted news personalities are moving into the same marketplace as other creators, with engaged, often affluent audiences and formats that suit sponsorship. That is an opportunity, but it comes with higher stakes. Brands should respect the editorial independence that makes these audiences valuable. A sponsor that tries to steer a news show will damage both the show and itself.

Why it matters: British journalism's biggest names are discovering that they can earn more, and keep more control, as creators. Publishers can treat each departure as betrayal, or they can match the creator economy's terms. The ones that refuse will become training grounds for talent that leaves as soon as it has an audience.

Read more: how creator-led brands are becoming media companies.

This is the view of The Collab Report's editorial board. Disagree? Tell us, and we may publish the best responses.