Australian shoppers say people, not ads, made them try new products. Here is what that means for creator budgets
A survey of 850 Australians from influence agency Social Soup found 27% of recent grocery triers named another person as their biggest influence, against 4% for all paid advertising. The numbers are striking, but they come from an agency that sells word of mouth.

New research from Australian influence agency Social Soup claims that recommendations from friends, family, creators and reviews drive more than six times as many new product trials as all paid advertising put together. Founder and chief executive Sharyn Smith presented the findings at a Social Soup briefing on Thursday, as Mediaweek, Mumbrella and B&T reported.
The study is a nationally representative survey of 850 Australians aged 18 and over. It is aimed at fast-moving consumer goods (FMCG) brands, which have a launch problem: the reports cite Nielsen data showing 76% of FMCG launches fail in their first year.
The headline numbers
Among main grocery buyers who had recently tried a new product:
- 27% said another person (a friend, family member, creator or reviewer) was the biggest influence on their decision.
- 4% named paid advertising, counting TV, social, digital and outdoor together.
The survey also found that trial is common and fast. 79% of main grocery buyers had tried a new food, drink or household product in the past three months. Of those, 51% bought it on the spot and 83% bought within a week of first seeing it.
Word of mouth keeps going after the purchase. According to the research, 78% of people who try something new tell others about it, reaching an average of 15.1 people each, and 62% of people who hear about a product from someone else go on to buy it.
Most of the talking happens offline
For creators, this is the most useful detail in the study. Only 6% of people said they posted about a new product on social media, against 68% who talked about it in person. Smith described those conversations as happening "in kitchens, in group chats, at the school gate and in social media", Mediaweek reported.
So the "people" in the 27% are mostly not creators. They are friends and family. Creators matter most to younger shoppers: those aged 18 to 34 are almost four times as likely as over-55s to name a creator as their biggest influence. Older shoppers lean the other way, with 45% of those over 45 saying they rely more on what they see in store.
That age split fits a wider shift in Australia, where creator marketing has grown into a sizeable category of its own.
Discounts buy a first purchase, not loyalty
Half of all new product trials were bought on special, and waiting for a special was the top reason shoppers held off. But a discount made little difference to whether people came back: 57% of those who bought on special bought again, against 55% of those who paid full price.
"Price promotion doesn't inspire loyalty," said Matt Jones, co-founder of Four Pillars Gin and host of the StoryWork podcast, who presented alongside Smith, according to Mediaweek.

AI is small, but growing in research-heavy categories
Only one in 30 shoppers used an AI tool to help decide on a new product. In household, personal care and health the figure rises to one in eight, where shoppers use AI to compare ingredients and summarise reviews.
"Brands that want to make the AI shortlist need real people talking about them first," Smith said, as reported by B&T and Mumbrella. Jones put it more bluntly: "We are now no longer in control."
Read the numbers with care
Some caution is needed. This is an agency's own research, and Social Soup sells exactly the service the findings favour: it says it has spent 19 years building a community of more than 200,000 people for brand trials. None of the three reports linked to a full methodology, fieldwork dates or margin of error.
The 4% figure is also narrower than it sounds. It is the share of recent triers who named paid advertising as their single biggest influence. It does not mean ads did nothing. A TV spot or a social ad can put a product in front of the friend who later recommends it, and shoppers are not always good at knowing what first made them notice something. The "six times" comparison is Social Soup's own framing.
Even so, the direction matches what brands keep reporting elsewhere: buying reach is easy to measure, while trust is harder to measure but drives the purchase. In the UK, brands have said much the same about the gap between influencer spend and proof of sales.
What it means for creators
- Pitch the conversation, not the reach. If most product talk happens offline, a creator's value is in starting talk that spreads to group chats and dinner tables. Show brands comments, shares and saves, not just views.
- Know your audience's age. The study suggests creators have the most pull with 18 to 34-year-olds. Creators with older audiences may need to tie content to the in-store moment.
- Write for AI summaries. In health, beauty and household categories, clear, honest reviews that explain ingredients and results are the kind of content AI tools summarise.
What it means for brands and agencies
- Rethink launch budgets. If discounts don't build repeat purchase, some promotion money could move into seeding, sampling and creator programmes that get people talking.
- Ask for the methodology. Before moving budget on the strength of agency research, ask for the full questionnaire, sample breakdown and fieldwork dates.
- Measure beyond last touch. Use control groups or market tests to see whether word of mouth and paid media work better together than apart.
Why it matters: Australian FMCG brands spend heavily to launch products that mostly fail. If this survey is broadly right, the cheapest lever, getting real people (including creators) to talk, is the one most launch plans underfund. That case is strongest for younger shoppers and weakest for older ones who still decide in the aisle.