Filters have no place in beauty ads. Britain and Ireland should ban them outright
Ireland's ad watchdog has upheld a complaint over a filtered fake tan post, five years after Britain's own filter rulings. Case-by-case judgements have failed. Norway and France show a simpler way.

The filter was called "Paris". It added warmth to three Instagram story images of a woman applying fake tan. In an advert for fake tan, that warmth is the product.
On 17 November Ireland's Advertising Standards Authority upheld a complaint about those stories, posted by the chef Trisha Lewis, who has more than 288,000 Instagram followers, to promote the tanning brand Bare by Vogue, according to The Journal. The complainant said Lewis had used the filter on all three images and that the posts were not clearly marked as ads. Lewis disagreed, saying every frame was labelled "paid partnership", and The Journal reported that she did not respond on the filter. The brand said any missed disclosure was "certainly not intentional" and that it does not ask creators to alter content in ways that could misrepresent how its products perform. The authority's Complaints Council upheld both complaints, finding the ad was not labelled clearly enough and that the brand had given no information explaining why the filter would not mislead people about how the product looks.
This is not a story about one creator. It is a story about a rule that has failed. Our view: regulators in Britain and Ireland should stop judging filters case by case and ban them outright from ads for products that change how skin, hair or faces look. Any other retouching of a person in an ad should carry a plain label, as Norway already requires.
Britain fixed this five years ago. Or thought it had
In February 2021 Britain's Advertising Standards Authority ruled against Instagram stories for two tanning brands, Skinny Tan and Tanologist, because beauty filters had made influencers' skin look darker than the product alone would. Headlines at the time said influencers had been banned from using filters.
It wasn't, because the ruling left the door open. The ASA said the use of filters in ads "is not inherently problematic". The problem, it said, was only a filter that exaggerated what the product could do. It advised influencers and brands to "avoid applying filters to photos or videos which are directly relevant to the product being advertised", and said the advertiser would have to prove a filter did not mislead.
"Avoid" is advice, not a rule. And proving that a filter is harmless is close to impossible, because filters are applied as the picture is taken. The ASA pointed this out itself: there is usually no unfiltered "before" image to compare against. Five and a half years later, a near-identical case has turned up in Dublin, involving the same kind of product and the same kind of filter.
Norway and France chose a bright line
Other countries stopped asking whether a particular filter crossed a particular line. Since 1 July 2022 Norway's marketing law has required a standard label, "retouched person advertisement", on any ad in which a person's body shape, size or skin has been altered, according to guidance from the Norwegian Consumer Authority. The label must cover about 7% of the image. Filters and lenses count. Changing skin colour counts. The rule applies to influencers and YouTubers as well as brands, and if retouching is suspected, the advertiser has to prove it didn't happen.
France followed with its influencer law of June 2023, which requires the words "images retouchées" on commercial content where an image has been edited to change someone's silhouette or face, and "image virtuelle" on AI-generated faces and bodies.
Neither rule depends on a regulator deciding, months later, whether a warm filter on a tanning ad was warm enough to mislead. Creators and brands know the rule before they post.
The case against, and why it falls short
There is a fair objection. Filters are part of the grammar of Instagram and TikTok. Plenty of creators use the same filter on every story so their feed looks consistent. A blanket ban, critics will say, punishes the honest majority for the tricks of a few, and sends regulators chasing colour grading instead of real scams.
But we are not proposing a ban on filters. We are proposing a ban on filters in ads for products whose whole job is to change how you look. A fake tan, a foundation, a serum, a lash product, a hair dye. In those ads the picture is the claim. If a creator cannot sell a tan without a filter that makes it look more tanned, the tan has not done the job.
The second objection is that small creators cannot be expected to know the rules. A bright line is exactly what helps them. "Don't filter beauty ads" fits in a contract clause and a single sentence of a brand brief. "Avoid filters that are directly relevant to the product, unless you can prove they don't exaggerate" needs a lawyer.

Ireland needs teeth, Britain needs nerve
Ireland's ad watchdog is self-regulatory and has no direct power to fine. It can ask for posts to be changed or removed. Since August 2025 it has been able to pass the names and handles of repeat offenders to the Competition and Consumer Protection Commission, which can issue compliance warnings, fixed payment notices and prohibition orders, and can prosecute, RTÉ reported. That route exists, and regulators should be seen to use it.
Britain is better armed. The ASA and the Competition and Markets Authority published the fourth edition of their joint influencer guide in October, and the CMA can now fine for consumer law breaches without first going to court. A clear filter rule for beauty ads would give both bodies something simple to enforce, and something brands could not claim to have misunderstood.
What it means for creators
Treat any paid post for a beauty, tanning, skincare or haircare product as filter-free, whatever the current rules say. Film it in good light and post it as it is. If you work with Norwegian or French audiences, you already have to label retouching. Keep your original files: in Norway the burden of proof is on you.
What it means for brands and agencies
The 2021 British rulings were clear that the brand is responsible even when the influencer applied the filter. Put a no-filter clause in every beauty contract and check stories before they are reposted. A brand that cannot show what its product looks like without a filter should ask why.
Why it matters: Beauty is a core category for influencer marketing, and filters are the easiest way to mislead within it. Five years of case-by-case rulings have not stopped filtered tanning ads. A plain rule would.
This is the view of The Collab Report's editorial board. Disagree? Tell us, and we may publish the best responses.