THE PULSE
the business of creativity
Insights

Europe just voted down its finfluencer rules. Britain is taking finfluencers to court instead

MEPs rejected the EU's retail investment directive by 14 votes, shelving rules that would have made firms sign contracts with finance creators and keep records of their posts. In the UK, the FCA is prosecuting creators one by one. Neither approach has solved the problem.

By · November 16, 2026
Image © The Collab Report

Last Thursday, the European Parliament had a finished set of rules for "finfluencers" in front of it. Investment firms would have had to sign written agreements with the creators who market their products, keep records of what those creators post, and make sure every sponsored video named the firm behind it. Negotiators had already agreed the text.

Parliament threw it out by 14 votes.

On the same issue, Britain is going the other way. It has no finfluencer-specific law at all, and it doesn't seem to want one. Instead, its financial regulator is taking creators to court. For creators who talk about money, and the brands that pay them, the gap matters.

What Europe just rejected

The vote on November 12 concerned the main directive in the EU's Retail Investment Strategy, a package meant to make investing safer and cheaper for ordinary savers. Agence Europe reported that MEPs rejected the agreement with the Council by 300 votes to 286, with 23 abstentions. A companion regulation, which redesigns the key information document that comes with investment products, passed by 311 to 261.

The finfluencer rules sat in the rejected directive. According to an October briefing by the law firm Skadden, the agreed text would have added a definition of a finfluencer to MiFID II, the EU's main investment-services law: any person "with the capacity to influence the behaviour, opinion or investment decisions of retail clients." Firms using finfluencers would have needed written agreements setting out what the creators could do. They would also have had to keep detailed records of the marketing, including the content, the channels, the dates and who posted it. Sponsored posts would have had to be identifiable as marketing and name the responsible firm.

Those finfluencer rules were not what sank the directive. The fight was over inducements, the commissions paid to the people who sell investment products, and a new "value for money" test on product costs. Agence Europe reported that the Socialists, Greens and Left were joined by some centre-right EPP and conservative ECR members, which tipped the result. Markus Ferber, the EPP's negotiator, had backed the deal in committee in June. After the vote he said, as Agence Europe reported: "This is not a vote against retail investors."

The rapporteur, the French Renew Europe MEP Stéphanie Yon-Courtin, put the finfluencer cost bluntly. In a statement from her group, she called financial influencers "financial advisors 2.0" and said the rule requiring them to disclose deals with product manufacturers "will be delayed indefinitely". "I very much regret this gift to online scammers," she said.

The file is not quite dead. Agence Europe, citing a parliamentary source, said the options include sending it back to the economic affairs committee for up to four months of further talks with member states. The law firm Linklaters also lists a broader reopening or a long stalemate. The European Commission said it would "consider possible next steps". Skadden had expected the rules to apply around mid-2029. That timetable has now gone.

Britain prefers prosecutions

The UK has taken a different route. As Skadden points out, it has no rules written specifically for finfluencers. Creators are covered by the general ban on financial promotions in section 21 of the Financial Services and Markets Act. In business, nobody may promote an investment unless an FCA-authorised firm has made or approved the promotion. Breaking that rule is a criminal offence, with up to two years in prison.

The Financial Conduct Authority has been using that power. In February, seven reality-TV personalities with a combined 4.5 million Instagram followers were sentenced at Southwark Crown Court for promoting an unauthorised foreign-exchange trading scheme, according to the FCA. In April, during an international "week of action" led by the FCA and involving 17 regulators, the FCA announced a guilty plea from the Geordie Shore personality Aaron Chalmers and new criminal proceedings against two more people.

That same week, the regulator said it had asked social media platforms to take down 120 accounts. Between them they carried 1,267 illegal financial adverts that had reached at least 2.3 million UK accounts on Meta's platforms. Two-thirds came from firms or people already on the FCA's warning list.

The trend is upwards. FCA figures obtained under freedom of information by the broker-comparison site BrokerChooser, reported by Professional Adviser in February, showed 74 enforcement actions against finfluencers in 2025, up from 27 in 2024 and one in 2023. A separate FCA freedom-of-information answer published in August describes two active criminal operations. One has produced seven convictions, with one person awaiting trial. In the other, six people have been charged: two have pleaded guilty and are awaiting sentence, and four are awaiting trial. Two more accepted police cautions and 12 received warning letters.

The weak spot in the British model

Prosecution makes headlines, not big penalties. The FCA's own list of the February sentences shows that the largest fine was £3,750. The others ranged from £600 to £974, and two of the seven received discharges. Prosecution is also slow and costly. The August FCA answer shows the two operations together have cost the regulator more than £240,000 in legal costs since mid-2023, and the first one started before then.

The FCA's own statements point to the deeper problem. It says social media platforms "are not doing enough to uphold their own policies to block illegal content", and it has asked them to stop illegal promotions at source. The British model chases the creator after the post has gone out. The rejected European model would have put the paperwork on the firm before the post went out.

In practice, Britain already puts much of that duty on firms through guidance. Skadden notes that under the FCA's social media guidance, a firm can be treated as having caused a promotion it did not write. That can happen, for example, when a creator uses the firm's referral link. The FCA also expects firms to have a policy for their affiliates, monitor them, and drop those who keep breaking the rules. Affiliate links, and posts made in the hope of future deals, can count as acting in the course of business.

Illustration: The Collab Report

Europe is not standing still

Brussels's failure doesn't leave European creators unregulated. A jurisdiction summary published today by the law firm Norton Rose Fulbright lists a growing patchwork of national rules. In France, the 2023 influencer law has, since July 1, banned online promotion of certain high-risk products such as CFDs, binary options and forex derivatives. Crypto can only be promoted for firms authorised under MiCA, the EU's crypto law, with fines of up to €100,000. Germany's BaFin published five points for influencers in August. Italy's media regulator AGCOM requires influencers with at least 500,000 followers or a million average monthly views to register.

A Europe-wide rulebook would have replaced that patchwork with one standard. For now, a finance brand running a campaign across five EU markets still has to deal with five sets of rules.

What it means for creators

If you talk about money in the UK, the rule is simple and strict. Promoting a specific investment, trading platform or crypto product for any commercial benefit, including an affiliate link, is a criminal offence unless an FCA-authorised firm has approved the promotion. In the EU, nothing changes this week. But the national rules in France, Germany and Italy already bite, and a revived EU text would make the firms paying you write everything down.

What it means for brands and agencies

Finance brands should not treat the Brussels vote as a reprieve. The obligations that were voted down, including written contracts, records of creator content and clear identification of the sponsoring firm, are much the same as what the FCA already expects from firms that use affiliates. Agencies running finance campaigns across Britain and Europe should build to that standard now. Any revived EU text will start from it.

Why it matters: Finance is one of the most lucrative categories in creator marketing and one of the most dangerous for audiences. Britain is prosecuting creators one by one for small fines, while Europe has just shelved rules that would have made the paying firms answerable. Neither has worked out how to stop illegal finance ads at scale. Until one of them does, the legal risk will keep falling on the creator holding the phone.