THE PULSE
the business of creativity
Breaking

EU says TikTok's For You feed breaks the law and should stop ranking videos on watch time

The European Commission has preliminarily found TikTok in breach of the Digital Services Act over the "rabbit hole" effect of its recommendations. Its proposed fix goes after the signal creators have optimised for years: viewing time.

By · November 6, 2026
Illustration: The Collab Report

The European Commission said on Friday that TikTok's For You feed appears to break the EU's Digital Services Act (DSA), because of what it calls a harmful "rabbit hole" effect. The Commission's preliminary findings go further than a warning. At this stage, the Commission says, TikTok needs to change how the feed is designed. One of its examples is to stop using viewing time as a signal for what to recommend.

That is the part creators should read twice: watch time has been the core measure of success on short-form video for years.

What the Commission found

The Commission's case is that the more a user interacts with one kind of content, the more of it the For You feed serves. It says that can be harmful when the content is about sadness, isolation, body image or weight loss, especially for minors and vulnerable adults.

The findings cover two failures:

  • Risk assessment: TikTok did not properly assess how its recommendation system can lead users into rabbit holes.
  • Mitigation: TikTok's existing safeguards don't work well enough. Its content-diversification measures don't cut repetition enough, and the "not interested" button may not be enough to change the feed. The Commission says the algorithm puts viewing time ahead of a user's choice to see less of something.

Its suggested fixes: rely more on users' explicit preferences, stop using viewing time to recommend content, make controls easier to use, and test the algorithm regularly.

"Every time a user scrolls or likes a video on TikTok, the algorithm serves more of the same leading users down rabbit holes they cannot easily escape from," Henna Virkkunen, the Commission's Executive Vice-President for Tech Sovereignty, Security and Democracy, said in the release.

TikTok's response

TikTok rejected the findings. In a statement reported by RTÉ and Reuters, the company said the Commission "has made a series of statements that are fundamentally inaccurate and distort our platform's architecture and our commitment to user safety". It added that it has "a strong record of protecting our community".

Image © The Collab Report

What happens next

This is not a final decision. TikTok can now examine the Commission's file and reply in writing, and the European Board for Digital Services will be consulted. If the findings are confirmed, the Commission can issue a non-compliance decision with a fine of up to 6% of TikTok's worldwide annual turnover.

It is the third set of preliminary findings against TikTok this year in an investigation opened in 2024, after findings on addictive design in February and protection of minors in July. Ireland's media regulator, Coimisiún na Meán, supported the investigation; TikTok's European headquarters is in Dublin.

The pressure is transatlantic. This week Google, Meta and TikTok sued California over a law targeting feeds and autoplay for under-16s. Tubefilter notes that earlier EU pressure already led TikTok to offer a non-personalised feed in Europe.

What it means for creators

If the Commission gets its way, the EU version of the For You feed would rank content less on how long people watch and more on what they say they want: follows, explicit preferences and "not interested" taps. Hooks, loops and retention editing would count for less; audiences that actively choose a creator would count for more.

Creators in wellness, fitness, diet and mental health should expect more scrutiny. Those are the categories the Commission named, and any redesign aimed at breaking up repetitive feeds would hit them first. The process could take months, and TikTok will fight it, but creators building European audiences should start tracking follows, saves and searches, not just watch time.

What it means for brands and agencies

EU reach estimates for TikTok campaigns assume today's algorithm. A forced redesign would change how creator content is distributed across 27 markets, likely favouring loyal, opted-in audiences over viral reach. Instagram Reels and YouTube Shorts work in a similar way, so any precedent set here won't stay with TikTok.

Why it matters: Europe's top tech regulator is telling the world's biggest short-video platform to stop ranking content on viewing time. If that holds, Europe will be the first big market where the attention economy runs on a different scoreboard, and creators will have to change how they play.