THE PULSE
the business of creativity
Insights

Italy already regulates influencers like broadcasters. Its first year is a warning for Brussels

AGCOM expected 2,000 creators to join its register and got more than 5,000 applications. As the EU proposes one ad label for every paid creator, Italy shows why deciding who counts as an influencer is the hard part.

By · November 11, 2026
Image © The Collab Report

On Wednesday the European Commission proposed that every paid influencer post in the EU should carry the word "advertisement" or "commercial collaboration", with no minimum audience size and with brands sharing the blame when creators get it wrong. We covered the details of the Digital Fairness Act this morning.

One country has already spent a year trying something tougher. Italy's communications regulator, AGCOM, now treats its biggest creators much like small broadcasters, with a public register, a code of conduct and fines of up to €600,000. Its first year shows what happens when regulators try to pin down who counts as an influencer, and why Brussels may have been wise not to try.

What Italy built

AGCOM adopted its guidelines and code of conduct for influencers in resolution 197/25/CONS on July 23, 2025. The resolution was published on August 5, 2025, according to the regulator's own FAQs. The rules apply in full to "relevant influencers": creators with at least 500,000 followers, or an average of one million monthly views, on at least one platform. Il Post reported that AGCOM also requires an economic activity linked to the content, such as sponsorships or brand deals, and that the follower test applies to each platform separately, not to a creator's combined total.

Creators who cross either line must join AGCOM's "list of relevant influencers". The registration web form opened on November 6, 2025, and the first deadline was February 5, 2026. The regulator says the list will be updated twice a year, by April 15 and October 15. AGCOM is clear that this is not a professional licence. It is a public list kept for transparency.

Joining the list brings duties that go well beyond a hashtag. Il Post reported that registered creators come under Italy's audiovisual media services code, the law that governs private radio and television. AGCOM can supervise their content with help from the Guardia di Finanza (the financial police) and the postal and communications police. Registered creators also have to disclose filters or editing software that significantly change how they or a product look.

The penalties

Il Post reported that failing to register when required can bring a fine of up to €100,000. For registered creators, content breaches can cost up to €600,000 and a suspension of up to six months. Il Sole 24 Ore reported a ceiling of €250,000 for general breaches, rising to €600,000 for content harmful to minors. AGCOM said it would not open any sanction proceedings until the list was published, Il Post reported.

The rules were contested inside the regulator from the start. Commissioner Elisa Giomi, the only member to vote against, said the code "fails in its objective of bridging the gap between the audiovisual world and the digital ecosystem", Il Sole 24 Ore reported. Her colleague Massimiliano Capitanio called it "a modern and common-sense measure".

Expected 2,000, got more than 5,000

When registration opened, AGCOM expected about 2,000 creators to sign up. By April it had received at least 5,000 applications, more than double the forecast, Il Post reported. A law firm, Giammatteo, put the total number of creators working in Italy at about 40,000.

Critics point to the views threshold. Books creator Carlotta Sanzogni told Il Post that creators with 20,000 to 50,000 followers can regularly reach a million views a month, and find it absurd to be grouped with stars such as Chiara Ferragni. Views are also counted differently on each platform: a fraction of a second can count on TikTok, while YouTube needs longer watch time. Creator Martino Wong told Il Post the thresholds were badly drafted and unbalanced, and pointed out that Instagram only shows 90 days of data, so creators cannot check the six-month average the rule asks for.

Lawyer Daniele Sorgente told Il Post that many people applied simply because, when in doubt, they would rather not risk a fine. Some of Italy's best-known names, including Chiara Ferragni, Giulia De Lellis and ClioMakeUp, added "In elenco Agcom" ("on the AGCOM list") to their bios, as the rules require. Sorgente warned that some applicants might add the phrase and then not appear on the list.

AGCOM said it would publish the list in the summer. A Giammatteo note in mid-August still described publication as "to be verified", and The Collab Report could not independently confirm when, or whether, the full list has gone live.

Illustration: The Collab Report

Italy's labels are already stricter than Brussels'

Italy's disclosure rules, set out in FAQs that AGCOM published on March 16, 2026, read like a preview of the EU proposal, with extra detail. According to a summary by law firm ADVANT Nctm:

  • Paid content must be immediately recognisable, using explicit words such as "Advertising" or "ADV". "In collaboration with" or "in partnership with" is not enough.
  • The label goes at the start of a caption, on screen in the opening scenes of a video and in its description, on every story frame, and continuously during a live stream.
  • Gifted products need "gifted by" or similar, and invited events need "invited by".
  • Labels should generally stay up for about three months after a collaboration ends.

These transparency rules apply to every paid creator in Italy, not just those on the list. AGCOM's FAQs say creators below the threshold are still expected to follow the rules on ad disclosure, fair commercial communication and the protection of minors.

Spain went the other way

Spain created its own register in 2024 with much higher bars: more than €300,000 in revenue the previous year, more than one million followers on one platform and at least 24 videos a year. By July 2024 only 54 creators had registered, Il Post reported. Between them, Spain and Italy show the problem with a threshold. Set it high and almost nobody is covered. Set it low, or base it on a slippery number such as views, and the regulator is buried in applications from mid-sized creators who earn far less than a TV channel.

What it means for creators

The Commission's draft avoids that trap. It has no follower or view threshold for the labelling rule, so it would cover every creator who promotes a product for money or freebies. The trade-off is that there is no small-creator exemption. For Italian creators, the Digital Fairness Act would not replace AGCOM's regime. Italy's rules come from audiovisual media law, while the Commission's proposal is consumer law, so creators there could end up answering to both. If you work with Italian brands or audiences, the safest course is already clear: use "ADV" or "Pubblicità" at the start, not "in collaboration with", and keep the label on.

What it means for brands and agencies

Italy is a live test of the brand-liability model Brussels wants to roll out. ADVANT noted that the risk of hidden advertising "does not concern only the influencer, but also the commissioning brand". Brands running pan-European campaigns should expect national rules like Italy's and France's to stay in force while the EU text is negotiated. Contracts should already specify the label wording, where it goes and how long it stays up, market by market.

Why it matters: Italy has shown how hard it is to decide who counts as an influencer. Its broadcaster-style register drew more than twice the expected applications and left mid-sized creators unsure whether they qualify. Brussels has chosen a simpler rule that covers everyone who is paid. How member states and the European Parliament handle that choice will decide whether Europe ends up with one standard or 27.