THE PULSE
the business of creativity
Opinion

Whitehall is right to pay influencers. The scandal is what it won't tell us

UK government departments paid creators at least £2.4m in two years, and the critics call it propaganda. It is good value for public money. The secrecy around it is not.

By Editorial Board · November 14, 2026
Image © The Collab Report

Over the past few months, Whitehall's spending on influencers has turned into a minor scandal in Britain. Government departments paid at least £2.4m to social media creators between July 2024 and July 2026, according to answers to parliamentary questions from Conservative MPs reported by IBTimes UK. The Department for Education was the biggest spender, at more than £700,000. HMRC spent £591,200, not counting agency fees, on 44 influencers. The Department for Transport, the Department for Work and Pensions, the Ministry of Justice and the Ministry of Defence each spent six-figure sums.

The reaction has been loud. The Conservative shadow minister Alex Burghart told LBC that ministers should be "delivering results, not funding social media campaigns", and called it "a constant stream of Government-funded propaganda". The Liberal Democrats' Munira Wilson told Tes it was "a kick in the teeth" for parents and teachers.

We think the critics have this the wrong way round. Paying creators to explain childcare support, tax returns and Universal Credit is one of the more sensible things Whitehall has done with its marketing money. The real scandal is how little the public is allowed to see about it.

The money is small, and it goes where the audience is

Start with the size. Across a dozen or so departments and two years, £2.4m works out at roughly £100,000 a month for the whole of government. The Department for Education's own figures, given in a written answer by minister Olivia Bailey and reported by Tes, put its influencer spend at £119,300 in 2024-25 and £589,671 in 2025-26. Bailey said those figures include fees, production and paid-media costs. Those are not trivial sums, but they are modest for a department that has to reach every parent and school leaver in England.

Then look at what the money was for. IBTimes UK reported that the campaigns covered the Best Start in Life childcare scheme, teacher recruitment, how to file a tax return, how to spot misleading tax advice on social media, moving to Universal Credit, and getting help to find work. That is not party propaganda. It is the kind of dull, practical information that people miss out on if it never reaches them.

And it increasingly doesn't reach them through the old channels. The people who most need to know about free childcare hours or a tax deadline are often young parents and first-time workers who don't watch the news or read a printed leaflet. They watch creators. A government that refuses to go where its citizens actually spend their time is not being careful with money. It is choosing to be ignored.

The Gemma Collins test

The most mocked example proves the point. In May, the Department for Education released videos in which the reality TV star Gemma Collins promoted vocational routes after 16. The department said she was not paid. Education Secretary Bridget Phillipson called the backlash "outright snobbery", PoliticsHome reported. Government sources told the same outlet that more than 80% of people who watched the video in its first few days did not follow the department.

That is the whole case for creators in one number. Most of the audience a department's own account reaches is people who already pay attention to it. A creator reaches people who don't. If you want teenagers who are unsure about university to hear that apprenticeships exist, a famous face from Essex will reach more of them than a press release from Sanctuary Buildings.

The DfE told Tes that influencers reach audiences "in a much more cost-effective way than traditional marketing techniques". It has not published the evidence for that claim, and it should. But the logic is the same one every major consumer brand in Britain now follows.

Where the critics are right

None of this means the spending is well run. The record so far is messy, and the critics have a fair point there.

The numbers don't add up neatly. Tes reported that the DfE had earlier told it that its 2024-25 spend was £80,950, not £119,300, and that the department declined to explain the difference. LBC reported that Downing Street refused to disclose its total, that the Ministry of Justice refused its request on public interest and commercial grounds, and that several departments said they did not hold the information. IBTimes UK reported that the Home Office and the Foreign Office said they keep no central records of payments to creators.

Ministers have also not published the full list of creators they paid, LBC reported. Some names have come out, such as the TV dancer Oti Mabuse and Billie Shepherd for the childcare campaign, but only piece by piece.

That is the indefensible part. A government that pays someone to speak to the public on its behalf owes the public the name of that person, the fee, the campaign and the results. If a department cannot say who it paid or what it got for the money, voters are right to assume the worst.

Image © The Collab Report

What Whitehall should do

The fix is not to stop. It is to publish. Every paid government creator partnership should appear on a single public register, updated quarterly, listing the creator, the department, the campaign, the fee and the headline results such as reach and completed sign-ups. Guidance introduced in 2023 already asks departments to vet creators before working with them, including their audience and any past political activity, IBTimes UK reported. A register would show whether that vetting actually happens.

Creators should welcome this too. Being paid by the state to talk about benefits or tax is a reputational risk. A clear public record, together with clear ad labels on every post, protects them from claims that they are secretly doing a party's work.

What it means for creators

Government is now a real client in Britain, and it pays for practical, useful content. Creators who take this work should expect their names to come out eventually, so they should label every post clearly and be ready to explain why they took the job. Those with audiences that are hard to reach, such as young parents, trades and first-time taxpayers, are the ones departments want most.

What it means for brands and agencies

Whitehall has reached the same conclusion as consumer marketers: traditional channels no longer reach large parts of the public on their own. Agencies that run public-sector creator work should build in the reporting a public register would demand now, because the political pressure for it is only going one way.

Why it matters: Britain's government spends a small amount reaching people through creators, and the case for doing so is strong. By refusing to say clearly who it pays and what it gets, it is turning a sensible policy into an easy target. Publish the register, and the row largely goes away.

Read more: how UK regulators are stepping up action on hidden influencer ads.

This is the view of The Collab Report's editorial board. Disagree? Tell us, and we may publish the best responses.