THE PULSE
the business of creativity
Opinion

France is right to hold big political creators to election rules. Britain and Australia should follow

Creators are outraged that Arcom will make the biggest political YouTubers give candidates equal time. The principle is sound. The method should be law, with a clear threshold, and London and Canberra should prepare it now.

By Editorial Board · November 20, 2026
Image © The Collab Report

For about five weeks next spring, France will ask a handful of YouTubers to do something every television channel in the country already does: if they put presidential candidates in front of their audiences, they must be fair about it, and in the final weeks strictly equal.

The reaction has been fierce. Jean Massiet, host of the political Twitch show Backseat, said he was "scandalized, outraged by this attack on fundamental freedoms" and was weighing legal action, according to The National Pulse. The MEP Sarah Knafo called it a "coup d'État against the internet". Critics have asked Reuters whether the rules can be enforced at all.

Our view is the unfashionable one. Arcom has the principle right. A creator whose political show reaches a prime-time television audience is, during an election, doing the job of a broadcaster, and should carry a broadcaster's duty of balance. Britain and Australia should prepare the same rule before their next elections. But it should be written by parliaments, with a clear audience threshold, not by a regulator on its own authority.

What France has actually asked for

The detail matters, because much of the anger is about a rule that does not exist. As we reported this morning, Arcom will treat a small number of creator channels as audiovisual media services for the April 2027 presidential election. To be covered, a channel must regularly cover news, politics or public debate, and have an audience comparable to a traditional broadcaster's. One viral video is not enough.

From March 16, covered creators must give candidates fair exposure. From April 5, the start of the official campaign, speaking time must be equal. Nobody is required to invite every candidate. Arcom president Martin Ajdari gave his own example of what would cross the line: an influencer who, during the official campaign, "invites one or two candidates and denigrates the others", The National Pulse reported. Penalties start with a warning, then a formal notice, with fines only for repeated breaches.

Ajdari told RTL radio that the rules would cover a "very tiny minority" of channels whose audiences run into the millions, and that "the vast majority of them will be able to carry on with their programmes as before." "We are not there to bother influencers," he said, according to Reuters.

The audience has already moved

The case for the rule is about reach, not about any individual creator. The Reuters Institute's 2025 Digital News Report found that HugoDécrypte, Hugo Travers's explainer channel, reaches 22% of French under-35s, mostly through YouTube and TikTok. That is the reach of a mass medium among the voters parties find hardest to reach.

Britain is heading the same way. Ofcom's own research has found that Instagram, TikTok and YouTube are now teenagers' top three news sources. In a few years those teenagers will be voters, and many will be getting their election coverage from people who are not bound by any of the rules that apply to the BBC, ITV or Sky.

Broadcast election rules exist for a simple reason. When a few outlets reach most voters, a democracy cannot leave it to each of them to decide which candidates the public gets to hear. That logic does not depend on whether the outlet has a transmitter. It depends on how many people are watching.

The objections, taken seriously

Massiet's strongest point is practical. "It is not possible to make a content creator, who has no legal status, follow the same rules, especially since we do not have the same budgets or resources as TF1 or the BFM/RMC Group," he told RMC radio, Reuters reported.

That is a fair objection to the burden, not to the principle. Balance does not require a newsroom. It requires a log of who appeared and for how long, and a willingness to offer comparable time to candidates you did not choose. A creator big enough to be covered is big enough to keep a spreadsheet.

The free-speech objection is weaker than it sounds. Nobody is stopping French creators from having opinions. Arcom has said that a politically committed editorial line does not exempt a channel, but nothing in the rule bans commentary. It governs one thing: how much airtime candidates get, for a few weeks, from channels with broadcast-scale audiences. Television presenters have lived with that for decades without becoming state mouthpieces.

Knafo's objection is the one that should worry Arcom most. "No law requires this of it: it has given itself this power all on its own," she said, according to The National Pulse. Arcom's route is to reclassify certain channels as audiovisual media under existing law, and creators' groups such as Umicc dispute that this is legitimate. The Conseil d'État may settle it. Even if Arcom wins, a rule this important to an election should have been voted on, not adopted by a regulator.

Illustration: The Collab Report

Britain and Australia are not ready

Neither country has an answer to the question France is trying to answer.

In Britain, Ofcom's election rules in the Broadcasting Code bind licensed television and radio. A political YouTube channel with a bigger young audience than some of those licensed services has no equivalent duty. The next general election must be held by 2029.

Australia's position is similar. Under Schedule 2 of the Broadcasting Services Act, a licensed broadcaster that airs election matter during an election period must give reasonable opportunities to all parties contesting the election that were represented in parliament. The duty is tied to licence categories that were written for television and radio. It was not designed for a YouTube or TikTok creator with a national audience.

The fix is not to copy Arcom's case-by-case test. It is to legislate a simple line: a published audience threshold, measured over months rather than one viral clip, above which a channel that regularly covers politics takes on a light duty of balance during the formal campaign. Below it, nothing changes. Creators would know where they stand, and regulators would not have to make it up as they go.

What it means for creators

If you run a large news or politics channel in Europe, Britain or Australia, assume this is coming. Start logging which politicians appear, and for how long, now. It costs little, and it is the evidence you would need to show you were fair.

What it means for brands and agencies

Sponsors of political and current-affairs creators should plan for election periods the way they plan for broadcast: expect more scrutiny, and check that sponsored formats, such as candidate interview series, can be balanced.

Why it matters: Once creators reach audiences the size of television's, the old argument for broadcast election rules applies to them too. France has moved first, and clumsily. Britain and Australia can do it properly, but only if they start before their next campaigns begin.

This is the view of The Collab Report's editorial board. Disagree? Tell us, and we may publish the best responses.