Stop paying creators by the sale for anything you inject, swallow or take on prescription
Australia's peptide scandal and Britain's weight-loss jab crackdown point to the same fix. Disclosure has failed. Regulators should ban commission-based pay for health products outright and let creators earn flat fees instead.

Today's ABC News investigation into Australia's black-market peptide trade, which we reported this morning, contains one sentence that sums up the problem. A 22-year-old Adelaide fitness influencer, who told the broadcaster he earned up to $2,000 a week in affiliate commissions from peptide sellers, explained his reasoning: "I figured if I take this stuff, I might as well get paid."
He is not the villain of this story. He is what the system pays for. The fix is not more warnings to creators like him. It is to take away the payment model that made his choice so easy.
Our view: in Australia, Britain and the EU, it should be unlawful to pay anyone a per-sale commission, discount-code cut or referral bounty for promoting medicines, injectables, prescription services or health supplements. Flat fees, clearly labelled, can stay. Paying by the sale should go.
Disclosure has been tried, and it has failed
For a decade the answer to bad health promotion online has been labelling. Say it is an ad, and the audience can judge for itself. That works for trainers and lipstick. It does not work when the product can put someone in hospital.
The ABC's figures show the scale. NSW Health counted 1,180 emergency department visits linked to unapproved peptides between July 2025 and September 2026, with monthly visits rising from 5 to almost 220. The Poisons Information Centre logged 345 peptide cases in the first half of 2026, more than three times the whole of 2025. A "#ad" on the post would not have changed any of that.
Australia already goes further than most. Since the Therapeutic Goods Advertising Code took full effect in mid-2022, influencers who are paid or gifted a therapeutic product cannot give a personal testimonial about it. In July the Therapeutic Goods Administration warned that influencers and affiliates who promote unapproved peptides "could also be held accountable for unlawful advertising", Medical Republic reported. The rules are on the books. The trade grew anyway.
Britain has already admitted the problem
Britain reached the same point by a different route. In February the Advertising Standards Authority issued its first rulings against social posts promoting prescription weight-loss injections through affiliate and referral schemes run by online pharmacies Voy, Zava and MedExpress and prescribing service UK Meds Direct, Aesthetics Journal reported. The ASA held both the companies and the people posting responsible. Its investigations manager, Catherine Drewett, put it simply: "affiliate marketing is not a loophole".
The detail that matters is who was posting. Some were ordinary customers sharing a code for a discount, not professional influencers. Once the incentive exists, anyone can become a drug promoter without realising it. Advertising prescription-only medicines to the public is already illegal in the UK. The affiliate model simply spread the illegal ads across thousands of accounts that no regulator can track one by one.

Why commission is the problem
A flat fee pays a creator to make a post. A commission pays them to make a sale. That difference changes the content.
Commission rewards the strongest claim, the most dramatic before-and-after and the most persuasive "it worked for me". It favours the creator who never mentions side effects. It means the person making the content earns nothing from being careful, and more from being reckless. For headphones, that is a business model. For something you inject, it is a public health risk.
It is also the part of the system that the rules can actually reach. Regulators cannot read every post. They can follow the money. Affiliate networks, payment processors and brands keep records of who they pay and for what. A ban on per-sale pay in health categories is far easier to enforce than a rule about tone in a 30-second video.
The fair objections
There are real arguments against this, and they deserve an answer.
"Black-market sellers will ignore the law anyway." Some will. But the ABC found more than 50 businesses selling to Australians, and the creators promoting them are public by definition. Removing the legal cover for commission deals makes every creator in those programmes an obvious target, and gives the platforms a clear rule to enforce.
"Honest creators will lose income." Some fitness and wellness creators earn a meaningful share of their living from affiliate links, and many promote legitimate products responsibly. They can still be paid, through flat fees, retainers and sponsorships. What they lose is the incentive to sell harder than the facts allow. That is a cost worth paying.
"Where do you draw the line?" At the categories regulators already treat as health products: medicines, prescription services, injectables, and supplements that make health claims. Protein bars and gym leggings stay outside. Lawmakers draw lines like this all the time.
Brussels has an opening
The European Commission is expected to unveil its Digital Fairness Act on November 11, with influencer marketing one of its targets. A ban on commission-based promotion of health products would be a simple, testable rule that 27 countries could apply the same way. It would also give Australia and Britain a model to follow.
Creators should support it. Today, when a health promotion goes wrong, the person with the smallest legal team and the biggest audience is the one who gets named. Taking commission out of health marketing protects them as much as it protects their followers.
Why it matters: Labels tell an audience that someone was paid. They say nothing about how the payment shapes what is said. In health, per-sale pay pushes creators towards bigger claims and riskier products, and the harm data from Australia shows where that leads.
Related: ABC investigation: Australian influencers are earning affiliate cash from black-market peptides and Hidden ads are consumer fraud. Fine the influencers who post them.
This is the view of The Collab Report's editorial board. Disagree? Tell us, and we may publish the best responses.