THE PULSE
the business of creativity
Opinion

Most Black Friday deals aren't real. Creators should stop pretending they are

Which? keeps finding that Black Friday prices are rarely the year's lowest, and Britain's CMA has started fining shops for fake urgency. Creators pushing "ends tonight" codes are doing the same job, and should check before they post.

By Editorial Board · November 21, 2026
Image © The Collab Report

Black Friday is on 27 November, and for many creators the next ten days will bring the most lucrative posts of the year. Swipe-up links, discount codes, "ends at midnight" stories and countdown stickers will fill feeds from London to Melbourne, each one paying the creator a commission when a follower buys.

Britain's consumer watchdog has just shown how it treats this kind of selling when shops do it. On 14 October the Competition and Markets Authority fined Wayfair £4.8 million and Appliances Direct £1.2 million for false urgency, in its first big round of fines under its new consumer-law powers.

Our view: a creator who tells their followers a "deal" is about to vanish, without checking whether it is real, is doing the retailer's fake-urgency marketing for it. Creators should stop. If they will not, the CMA should make one of them its next test case.

The deals mostly aren't deals

This is not a hunch. Which?, the British consumer group, has tracked Black Friday prices every year since at least 2020, and the result barely changes.

A study it published in November 2025 followed 175 home, tech and health products at eight big retailers, including Amazon, Argos, Currys and John Lewis, across Black Friday 2024. Every one of them was the same price or cheaper at some point in the six months either side of the day. None was at its lowest price of the year on Black Friday.

The year before, Which? found 92% of the deals it checked could be had for the same or less at another time. It also found 14 "was" prices that the retailer had not charged at any point in the previous 12 months.

The retailers dispute how this is read. Amazon pointed out that Which? had analysed just 24 of its products, against hundreds of thousands of deals. AO said an earlier study was based on only 2% of its Black Friday deals. Some shoppers do save money. But the claim that Black Friday is a rare, vanishing chance to buy cheaply is, on this evidence, mostly not true.

Creators are now part of the sales machine

Creators are not neutral messengers in this. A post with an affiliate link or a commission-earning code is an advert in Britain. The Advertising Standards Authority's guidance says affiliates are "effectively acting as a secondary advertiser", and the advertising code applies to them. The ASA has ruled that a lone "affiliate" label is not clear enough. The post has to say it is an ad.

That matters because advertisers have to be able to stand behind what they say. A creator who posts "only today" over a price that was the same last month, or will be the same next month, is making a claim they have not checked, to people who trust them more than they trust a retailer's banner.

Look again at what the CMA fined. Wayfair ran "Flash Deals" with countdown timers and lines such as "Here Today, Gone Tomorrow", when many products stayed at the same price or lower after the deadline. Appliances Direct ran pop-up countdown banners for discounts of £10 to £25 whose codes reappeared for days. Hayley Fletcher, the CMA's senior director for consumer protection, said: "The time is up for this kind of behaviour."

Swap the website banner for a creator's story with a countdown sticker and a code, and much of the selling technique is the same. The difference is that the creator's version is more persuasive, because it comes from a face the follower knows.

The case for going easy, and why it fails

There is a fair argument on the other side. Creators usually take the retailer's word for the price. They cannot see a shop's pricing history, and many earn a big share of their annual income in the final quarter. Blaming the person at the end of the chain, rather than the business that set the price, can look unfair.

Some of that is right, and retailers should carry most of the legal risk. But checking takes minutes. Which? and free price trackers publish price histories. Creators who build their audience on "I only recommend what I'd buy" are selling exactly that judgement. Passing on a deadline they have not checked trades it away for a commission.

Europe offers a simple standard. Across the EU, when a shop advertises a price cut, the "before" price has to be the lowest it charged in the previous 30 days. Britain relies on guidance rather than a fixed rule like that. Creators do not need a law to adopt the same test for themselves.

Image © The Collab Report

What should change

Three things, starting this Black Friday.

Creators should check the price history before posting a deal, and say so: "I checked, and this is the lowest price since the summer" is a stronger sales line than a countdown sticker, and an honest one. If they cannot check it, they should drop the urgency language.

Brands and affiliate networks should give creators the price history with every Black Friday brief, and stop asking for "last chance" copy on offers they know will return.

The CMA should make clear, publicly and before 27 November, that paid creators using false urgency are within its sights. The ASA and CMA's joint guide for influencers, now in its fourth edition since 2018, is mostly about how to label ads. Regulators should also say plainly that a creator cannot call a deal "ending" when it is not.

What it means for creators

Black Friday income is real, and nobody is asking creators to give it up. The ask is to stop lending your credibility to claims you have not tested. Audiences notice when "today only" comes back next week, and that damages trust you will need long after the season is over.

What it means for brands and agencies

A brand that asks creators to post fake deadlines risks both a regulator and its own partners. The CMA can now fine a business up to 10% of its global turnover. Briefs, codes and countdowns given to creators should pass the same test as the brand's own website.

Why it matters: Britain's regulator has started fining shops for fake urgency at the same moment creators have become one of the main ways Black Friday is sold. If creators keep repeating claims the evidence says are mostly untrue, it may be a regulator, not their audience, that stops them.

This is the view of The Collab Report's editorial board. Disagree? Tell us, and we may publish the best responses.